The 5 year old girls stared at the moving screen with wonder. Mouths open and eyes glued as Ashley Tisdale strutted up and down the stage singing ‘Bop to the top’ from High School Musical. “She’s so pretty,” one of the girls managed to say, her heart beating fast, as the excitement grew within her. “When I grow up, I want to be just like her!” another one exclaimed. The girls were packed tightly together sitting on a black futon in the living room. They had closed the curtains to make it seem more like a movie theatre and were fidgeting in their seats, like any other 5 years olds would. “Don’t forget, shes so popular too,” said the third little girl. And just like that, Sharpay Evans became these girl’s role model, not because of her acting skills or the fact that she could sing well, but purely for the fact that she was popular and pretty.
It turns out this was not an isolated incident. These days media tends to corrupt young girls minds and snatch away their childhood by shaping them to believe that the only way to be happy, is to be perfect. Sadly they are not just being told this by TV shows and movies but also by their best friends, their dolls. To girls, dolls are everything. Girls have to take care them, yet the doll is still their role model. Girls spend countless hours playing with their dolls and it is known that the more time you spend with something the more influence it has on you. But what happens when that influence the dolls give are negative?
Bratz dolls come with high fashion clothes and accessories, that include, high heels, purses, makeup and even fashion magazines. The slogans that come with the dolls are definitely worse. They say things like “passion for fashion”, “above all else be beautiful” and even their sportz bratz says “It’s not about how you play the game, its about how good you look when you win”. There is even a Bratz boyz line of dolls which are supposedly the Bratz boyfriends. And even the Baby Bratz comes with studded earrings, manicured nails and designer diapers. Do we really want young girls wearing thick makeup, high heels and having boyfriends? I don’t think so.
Now lets not forget the worlds favourite doll, barbie. You're probably remembering all those times that barbie helped you get through those rough primary school years, but did you know all the harmful effects barbie was leaving on you? The average girls, aged 3-11 owns around 10 barbies and as mentioned before the more time you spend with something the more impact it leaves on you. Barbie has had a countless number of jobs in the past years including, teachers, doctors and even a army officer but yet what is her most famous and advertised look? A skinny teenage fashion designer. In 1965 Mattel came out with a ‘slumber party barbie’. This barbie came with a weighing scale set to 110 lbs as well as a book on how to lose weight, which said things like ‘Don’t eat’.
In the US there are approximately 5 million females under the age of 20 who have eating disorders. Out of that most people said they became conscious about their weight between the ages 4 and 6 and that their dolls had some impact on them. Little girls spend hours putting on makeup, ruining their hair with dyes and curling irons and even pleading their parents to buy them the trendiest clothes. In a survey of 9 - 10 year olds, 40% said that they had tried to lose weight. Of course this doesn’t just end there.
It is known that kids minds are more open and can be easily molded into acting or thinking a certain way. It is also known that the things you learn when you are younger stick to you forever, especially when you see them throughout your life. This is exactly what is happening to young girls now. It just moves from the perfect barbie dolls to the to the perfect models on posters and magazines.
Blayke Roberts a model for the ‘healthy is the new skinny’ campaign said, “People kept saying, ‘oh you won’t fit into that, i’ll just find someone else’ and hearing that everyday and seeing all these other perfect models every day really gets to you. I used to think maybe I am too ugly and fat for this. I went to extreme measures, like eating 700 calories a day, running over three miles a day and I eventually became so sick.” This is just one out of many examples of girls who have been harshly affected by the media around her. And all of this implicitly began with those perfect little dolls and perfect girls on TV.
Another woman in the UK, named Sarah Burge spent over 1 million dollars to achieve the barbie look and currently spends over 10,000 thousands dollars a year to maintain that look. As you can tell this all started by her playing with her little barbie dolls.
Adding to that, another negative impact caused by the media is the expectations. According to Akanksha Shukla, a grade 8 student, “In a lot of shows, the actors choose to play younger roles than they actually are. So even now when I’m older, when I look at TV shows and someone’s playing a 14 year old, they are not going to look 14, they look 16. And then I look at myself and say, I’m 14 but compared to them I look about 4. I don’t dress the way they do but I feel, should I be dressing they way they are? The idea that they paint is that you have to pretty, popular and somehow manage to stay smart and when I was younger I felt like I had to have that one best friend and I had to have a boyfriend and I had to have all these things and if I didn’t I wasn't a real teenager. It’s not always true, just the media makes it seem like that.”
Akanksha’s comments reminds us on how many mind games the media can play on a young girl's mind. It can make you doubt yourself, want to change yourself and creates expectations that are beyond reachable for the average person. Do we really want this to be what is going on in little girls heads?
Do you remember at the start of this article there were three little girls watching high school musical and wishing they were Sharpay. Well one of those girls was this reporter. Young girls don’t realize what is happening to them while it is happening to them. That is why we need to make everyone aware of the negative impacts media is leaving on little girls. I was lucky enough to have heard a talk from Dannielle Miller who inspired me to take a stand. Dannielle Miller is feminist, counselor and presenter of self esteem workshops for girls. According to her, here are some solutions to this horrifying problem.
The first thing you should do is deconstruct the media. This means that you should look at it from a critical angle and start a conversation with your friends or family about what it really means. Another thing you can do is reassure young girls. Go out and let them know what the media is actually doing and make them aware. If we can stop this problem right at the source, it could actually save many girls from disaster. The third thing you could do is connect with other like- minded girls. I’m pretty sure you would be able to find a couple girls that care about this issue and then don’t forget to speak up. Your voice is a powerful tool and if everyone was aware about what was going on, I could assure you that there would be change, and there needs to be.
Written by Aditi
I enjoyed reading this post, because it shows girls that want to be like "Sharpay Evans" no matter of what age that they don't need to aim to being super skinny and super popular or looking super pretty. A good thing about life is you can interact with the people you want to interact with and you shouldn't feel obliged to be like the "cool kids" or the people who do all the childish fun stuff they want to do. It makes me wonder why some people judge others just because they are doing something stupid. I am sure that I will do a lot of stupid things in my life, but you learn from mistakes. Parents tell their kids not to drink or smoke because thy are too young, but they may not tell you that they were doing that when thy were your age. I am not trying to tell people to do stupid stuff on purpose, cause it can have a bigger effect than you think.
ReplyDeleteThankyou for your comment! I love what you are saying about how we get judged for the stupid things we do and I know I do a lot of stupid things so obviously that is another aspect of this which I might like to explore. Thanks :)
DeleteI like this idea, of commenting on real life events that have impacted certain people. I can connect with this because my cousins know 'high school musical' and act a bit as the three girls that you talked about. However, it does not always give a negative impact. Sometimes this just happens because the children are still young and to be pretty is all they care about. When they grow up most of them will realise that being pretty and popular is not the only thing in life that is good to have, you can still have a great life without it. I do wonder if the producer and writer thought about that it could have a negative impact towards children. Instead of just earning money, it is important to know the consequences.
ReplyDeleteThank you for your comment. I do agree with you that not always does all of this lead to complete disasters and young girls do sometimes just want to feel pretty but sometimes it can lead to negative impacts. And even if it's not everyone, the more people we can stop from getting hurt by the media the better :)
DeleteI agree with what has been said. Young females are easily influenced and if they grow up with something they are likely to believe. They will pay more time on their looks then on school and eventually they will become unsuccessful in life which started at a very young age. From this article I started to wonder why girls would want to live most of their life so miserable and just a a couple of years of actual fun. Why do humans want to be the prettiest? Do people not know that on the covers of magazine the women are all photshopped?
ReplyDeleteI really love the questions you have thought of! I think that girls want to be the prettiest because they are subconsciously trying to impress people, but I just realised when did we decided that the prettiest people have to have the most flawless skin and perfect hair. Why are humans minds programmed to see that as pretty and otherwise as ugly? I also do think that people realise that media is changing how models look and magazines and posters but they don't realise by how much. Sometime girls don't understand that some of the edits they make are almost humanly impossible but they try to copy it anyways. I'm not sure but thats just what I think. Thanks for your comment, really appreciate it :)
DeleteThe blog explores a very deep message of self image. the media can make us believe that we need to look like a certain way to be attractive. Should we educate young girls so they know what the media is portraying.
ReplyDeleteYes that would be great!!! If you could, you should go out and start a campaign and let not only young girls but everyone know what the media is doing. Like I mentioned at the end of my article, the main reason this is happening is because people don't really realise it is happening, so we need to make people aware. I just started of by writing this article and getting it online and I'm hoping to make more people aware about the issue and try to do something about it. Thankyou for your comment!
DeleteI agree with this post, because I think that this is a very important topic that needs to be addressed. Industries need to stop creating this image of the "perfect" girl, because it makes young girls believe they have to be perfect, or they will not be happy. Girls need to realize that it is impossible to actually be "perfect", and should concentrate more on being the best that they can be. Industries have a big impact on young girls, and should realize the dolls among other things that they are producing and selling just to make money are making young girls feel insecure about their bodies, and themselves in general.
ReplyDeleteYes that is exactly what my message is! We need to make everyone aware of the problems media is causing and try and explain to large industries that they need to change something. Thankyou for your comment :)
DeleteThis was a very interesting post because I´ve seen and experienced a lot of these things myself. Sharpay was actually one of my idols when I was younger and I got a lot of inspiration from watching the movies and wanted to be like her, look like her etc, but obviously, I didn´t succeed because I realized and understood that how she is/behaves isn´t normal. It´s a movie, and this is what younger children don´t really understand. They can´t see the difference between real life and a movie. You can´t, or at least you shouln´t, just totally change yourself from one day to another (in a bad/mean way) just because you watched a movie that you got inspiration from.
ReplyDeleteThat is very true. I'm glad that you got the message I was trying to send across! Now we need to try and make more people aware of the problem. Thank you for your comment :)
DeleteThis is an amazing story. A lot of girls grow up with the privileges that comes with owning a barbie or a bratz doll but most of the time parents and kids themselves don't realize the affect it has. A non speaking doll that looks the same everyday would probably not be harmful but your article reveals that it is. I think the way you made yourself grow within this article was a great idea and a cool effect that shows the change of a person as they grow older. :) I think your article has a great message and more people should be aware of the affect that dolls have on little girls.
ReplyDeleteIf you're interested check this video out :): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zRlpIkH3b5I
Thanks Seika!!
DeleteI really like and agree with this article. Many of the girls who when they are little like Barbies, grow up wanting to be a Barbie. This is something that damages their health a lot because Barbies are made really thin and they are supposed to be the "perfect girl" but being the perfect girl is almost impossible. It requires being thin, tall, having big eyes, and many more things and I agree with what she was saying that it should be all around the media with the intention of being girls' role model. Even when I was a small kid I wanted to be just like a Barbie, now I can see it is not I'll do.
ReplyDeleteBest wishes,
Nina Malé, 8th gr.
ASFG, México
Thank you so much for your comment! I am glad you got the message of my article and were able to relate and understand the meaning behind it. :)
DeleteI really liked your article. I agree with all the information you put. When I was younger I wanted to be like Barbie and the "perfect girl". Little girls don't know how to compare real life to movies. If this image keeps appearing in the life of girls, they will try to be just like this actors are. This really affects girls because if they see it since they are little, they will grow thinking this way. I think this was a great post because it teaches you that you have to be you no matter what.
ReplyDeleteBest wishes,
Andrea Arriaga, 8th gr.
ASFG, México
That is so true! We need to educate everyone and especially young girls so that they understand what is really happening to them. Thanks so much for the comment :)
DeleteAll what this article tells it's true. Lots of girls want to grow up and be perfect just like Barbie. I personally didn't like Barbie for the fact that she had everything and I didn't. Still lots of girls grow up perfectly with Barbie been there best friend as kids. I think that it all depends on what type of person you are. The problem is that all the girls want is a Beautiful doll and I've seen more normal looking dolls but still girls prefer Barbie and want everything that has the word Barbie in it.
ReplyDeleteBest wishes
Sofia Amador 8th gr.
ASFG, México
I agree with you in the sense that yes, not every girl will turn into a total disaster after owning a barbie doll but it can have some negative implicit impacts. Of course this does not happen to everyone and it shouldn't but we need to become aware of the possibilities and there have been some situations where this has gone totally wrong. I definitely agree with what you say though. Thanks a lot for your comment!!
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you about Barbie, she is a toy made to make girls think that they have to be a size 0 to be a doctor and solve cancer. Recently a book was released called "Barbie: I can be a computer engineer" that is completely sexist. It shows that Barbie could only design the game and had the boy's code the game and do all the hard work while she takes the credit at the end. In short it says girls cant do anything without boys and to just learn match the pretty colors. That was only one of the many sexist and pathetic messages that the Barbie company has tried to send out to poor innocent girls all over the world. Barbie is a sick tool made by men to make girls try to fit their image of the perfect girl, not allowing them to be themselves but a "perfect human copy" of a toy.
ReplyDeleteValentine Berdegué, 8th gr.
ASFG, México
Thank you so much for your comment! I love how fired up your are about the topic and now we need to take the anger and spread the word. I had no idea about the Barbie book so thanks for letting me know. I do understand that barbie leaves a lot of negative impacts though however I am not necessarily saying that we should remove barbie from all store shelves as to some she is just a companion through the toddler years. I do though believe that Barbie should be changed and portrayed differently so that she leaves less harmful impacts. Thanks again :)
DeleteI agree with this article says it's true all little girls want is to be just like Barbie. I never liked Barbie but my little sister does and once she told me that she wanted to be perfect like Barbie. I don't understand why little girls want to be just like Sharpay, I remember that she wasn't the brightest. Now little girls are preferring to be pretty or popular than being smart. I've had this type of conversation before with my mother and she told me that she didn't think that a doll might affect a girls life she thinks there are other stuff that girls grow up to be just like Barbie but it isn't the Barbie doll.
ReplyDeleteBest wishes
Viviana Diaz, 8th gr.
ASFG, Mexico
That is possibly true that it is not totally the dolls fault but I think it is a combination of many things including all types of media that are affecting young girls. There were many other forms of media I hadn't addressed in the article which leave negative impacts on young girls including magazines and posters all around. Thank you though for the comment and I am really glad you understand the main message of my article :)
DeleteHey,
ReplyDeleteI agree with your article because many little girls like barbies and sometimes this makes them want to grow up and be a barbie. This is a huge problem because this leeds to health problems and body image complications. I remember how it was better to be smart and now everything changed, stereotypes think it is better to be pretty and popular than smart.
Sincerely,
Ana Sofia 8th grade
ASFG, Mexico
Yay!! That is exactly the message I wanted people to get from my article. Now we need to spread awareness and let everyone know what is going on. Thanks!!!
DeleteI agree on everything. Since we are little the media such as commercials show barbie as the "perfect" girl. This influence can then cause major things such as anorexia and bulimia because barbie is really thin and what they are showing people is that you have to be like that in order to be "perfect". Industries should definitely stop showing barbie as an example to follow so we prevent more of this cases.
ReplyDeleteJimena 8th grade
ASFG, Mexico
That is exactly what I wanted people to get from my article. Thank you so much and now please share this knowledge with everyone you know, so we can raise awareness and stop this problem.
DeleteHey Aditi !!
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your article. I agree with everything you said, but I think girls are more influenced with TV shows, than Barbies dolls. Today, I know girls that are 7-8 years old and they already have an iphone!! There are all type of stereotypes today in the social media. I agree when you said that now the girls from the TV shows, (specially Disney channel shows) that are supposed to have 14 years old look like a 16 year old teen. It has a very bad influenced to all the little girls and I think bullying is a consequence of this. There is not a single movie that doesnt have the popular girl that tries to ruin the other girl life because she is ugly, or she likes to read, etc. I really enjoy reading your article, we need to start making a change.
Best wishes,
Fer DLM, ASFG
Mexico
Thank you so much! I do agree that it is not plainly the fault of the dolls that this is happening but a collection of all the media around us. There are many other forms of media affecting young girls as well which I hadn't mentioned in the article including magazines and general posters. I only really went into details bout dolls because those are something that I think many young girls treasure but TV shows and movie are also a main influence. Yes, we do need to start making a difference as well and the first thing you can do is raise awareness and share your knowledge with everyone you know so that we can see some results.
DeleteI really agree with what your saying! I think that it is a bad thing that girls grow up with the idea that barbies are "perfect and that they should try to be like them. I really think the same way as you it is totally wrong! Barbies are not perfect studies have been made and if a barbie existed with everything that way, it would be anorexic and it couldn't even walk because that is not perfection, its isn't real either. I loved your article. Great job!
ReplyDeleteBest wishes
Andrea Muñoz, 8th gr.
ASFG, Mexico
Thank you so much!! Now we need to raise awareness and let everyone know what is going on :)
Delete